Understanding Hip Impingement in Teens: How it Happens and How to Prevent It

Understanding Hip Impingement in Teens: How it Happens and How to Prevent It

Also commonly referred to as hip impingement, femoroacetabular impingement is a painful condition that occurs in the hips of adolescents and young adults. Two bones fit together to make up this “ball and socket” joint including the head of the femur (ball), which is part of the thigh bone, and the acetabulum (socket), which is part of the pelvis.

Impingement, or pinching, causes pain when the bones in the hip joint pinch the labrum, the soft tissue on the perimeter/edges of the acetabulum.
There are three types of FAI:

  • Cam impingement occurs when the shape of the femoral head or ball is abnormal.
  • Pincer impingement occurs when the shape of the acetabulum or socket is abnormal.
  • Combined impingement occurs when both the ball and the socket are abnormal.

Pediatric orthopedic surgeon Henry B. Ellis, M.D., says, “Repetitive activities make changes in the joints. In the hip, either the soft tissues become damaged, the bone actually changes its shape or both of these occur.” The reason for abnormal bone shape is not known. It may occur during development or may be in response to activity.

Symptoms of hip impingement are more likely to occur in those who perform:

  • Repetitive maximal flexion (bending) of the hip, such as deep squatting or high kicking.
  • Repetitive movements in activities, such as running, dance, gymnastics and hockey.

What are the symptoms of femoroacetabular impingement?

  • Pain in the hip or groin, typically in the front.
  • Tenderness and/or swelling of the hip or groin area.
  • Stiffness or pain after sitting for long periods of time.
  • Aching or pain that worsens with certain activities.

How is it diagnosed?
A thorough history and physical examination are used to diagnose a hip impingement. In most cases, X-rays are used to further assess the shape and fit of the bones. If symptoms do not improve or worsen, additional imaging such as an MRI or MR arthrogram may be recommended to further evaluate the soft tissue, the acetabular labrum. An MR arthrogram uses MRI, fluoroscopy and sometimes an injected medication to show the structures inside the joint.
 
How is it treated?
Treatment depends upon the severity of the condition and typically begins with a nonoperative approach which typically includes resting from activities that cause pain or changing to activities that do not. Other treatment options include physical therapy, joint injections or arthroscopic surgery may be required.
 
In a recently published article “Risk Factors for Suboptimal Outcome of FAI Surgery in the Adolescent Patient”*, Ellis and others reported findings after reviewing 126 hips (114 patients) under the age of 18 who were being treated for symptomatic FAI. This work helps Ellis and his colleagues around the country provide better counseling to patients considering surgery for FAI.
 
Early recognition and treatment are important because hip impingement has been shown to be a risk factor for early development of osteoarthritis of the hip.
 
How can hip impingement be prevented?
Overuse injuries like hip impingement and FAI occur with a high volume of training, repetition of certain movements and early specialization in a sport.
 
“Hip impingement in a growing child is bad news. We need to help them monitor and modify their volume of repetitive activities to prevent the condition from worsening, or even better, developing.”

  • Henry B. Ellis

These suggestions can help to prevent FAI and other similar overuse conditions:

  • Avoid sports specialization and play multiple sports throughout high school.
  • Emphasize moderation with load and training.
  • Encourage free play and lifetime sports like cycling and hiking.
  • Avoid year-round participation and encourage weekly and seasonal rest from activities requiring repetitive maximal flexion of the hip.
  • Perform proper warm-up and conditioning for all activities.                                                           

Learn more from Ellis about Hip Injuries in Young Athletes.
 
*Yen, Y. M., Kim, Y. J., Ellis, H. B., Sink, E. L., Millis, M. B., Zaltz, I., Sankar, W. N., Clohisy, J. C., Nepple, J. J., & ANCHOR Group (2024). Risk Factors for Suboptimal Outcome of FAI Surgery in the Adolescent Patient. Journal of pediatric orthopedics44(3), 141–146.

Dr. Carol Wise & Her Groundbreaking Scoliosis Research Timeline

Dr. Carol Wise & Her Groundbreaking Scoliosis Research Timeline

At Scottish Rite for Children, one of the most common conditions we treat is adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS). With AIS, the spine curves or twists into a “S” or “C” shape for unexplained reasons. It affects two to three percent of school-aged children, equating to millions of children worldwide. It is well known that girls have a much higher risk of developing severe AIS than boys, and that it tends to run in families. Despite this knowledge, much is still unknown about the cause of scoliosis, and there is currently no way to prevent the condition from occurring.
While our surgeons treat AIS in our clinics and operating rooms, Scottish Rite’s director of Translation Research Carol Wise, Ph.D., continues her groundbreaking scoliosis genetic research two floors above. Dr. Wise and her team have received millions of dollars in grant funding, and their breakthroughs in research are advancing the world’s understanding of scoliosis. Below is an overview of her discoveries, what she and her team are studying now, and where she hopes her research will lead in the future to help patients with scoliosis around the world.

Where It Started
In 2016, Dr. Wise was awarded a grant from the National Institutes of Health for a Program titled “Developmental Mechanisms of Human Idiopathic Scoliosis”. This program is a collaborative effort between three research-focused centers including Principal Investigators Dr. Wise at Scottish Rite for Children and University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Liliana Solnica-Krezel, Ph.D., at Washington University and Nadav Ahituv, Ph.D., at the University of California, San Francisco. The goal of the Program is to discover the causes of AIS in children.
In the first six years of the program, the researchers discovered many genetic variants associated with increased risk of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis. For example, one discovery was near PAX1, a gene involved in spine development. Curiously, this variant was found mostly in females and not males, suggesting it promotes the higher instance of AIS in females. The collaborative team went on to show that specific factors in cartilage, are relevant in AIS. This was a significant breakthrough as it pointed to specific parts of the spine that drive the disease. These findings were published in the journals Nature Communication and Bone Research.
In 2022, Wise and the team were awarded a highly competitive renewal of their grant. The goals of the new grant are to continue building on groundbreaking genetic research and define specific factors causing AIS that could be targeted for treatment. The group expanded with a fourth research center by adding Principal Investigator Dr. Gray of University of Texas at Austin.

Current Research
In a study published in January of 2024, Wise and her team defined still more genetic variants that function in cartilage and connective tissue and increase the risk of developing AIS. One of these variants was found in a gene called Col11a1, a gene variant affecting collagen. To further investigate, when PAX1 – the gene previously discovered to impact spine development – was removed, Col11a1 was reduced, limiting collagen production. Going one step further, the researchers found that lowering the levels of an estrogen receptor altered the activation patterns of Pax1Col11a1, and Mmp3 in mouse cartilage cells. These findings suggest a possible mechanism for the development of AIS, particularly in females. This information may guide future therapies aimed at maintaining healthy spinal cells in adolescent children, particularly girls. This work was published in the journal eLife. At the same time the UCSF team, using a different approach, discovered that estrogen blockade alters functions of Pax1. This work was published in Cell Reports. Dr. Wise and her team are continuing to define the roles of human AIS-associated genes in spine using animal models and other tools.  Simultaneously, they are sharing their findings with the larger scientific community for the benefit of spine researchers worldwide.

Future Research and Goals
As Wise and the group continue unraveling the “why” of AIS it is leading to ideas for prevention or cures. Developing pre-clinical therapies, and understanding why girls are at such greater risk of progressive AIS than boys, are two major goals of Wise and her colleagues. For Dr. Wise, patients and families living with AIS inspire her work and the work of many other scientists diligently seeking answers.

Summer Safety with William Morris, M.D.

Summer Safety with William Morris, M.D.

William Z. Morris, M.D., knows pediatric trauma and knows what it’s like to be a parent. As a pediatric orthopedic surgeon, his experience in the operating room has led him to raise awareness about some of the risks associated with lawn mowers and ATVs.
 
“I wouldn’t let my young kids use or be around a lawn mower,” says Morris. “It’s estimated that there are over 9,000 pediatric lawn mower injuries a year. One large study showed that about half of these injuries occur in kids 5 yrs of age or under. Lawn mowers can cause pretty terrible injuries that can result in amputations, most frequently in the lower extremities. In fact, around a quarter of all traumatic amputations in children are attributed to lawnmowers.

The second thing I wouldn’t let my young kids do is ride an ATV or all terrain vehicle. Injuries from ATV accidents are serious with one study showing almost 90% of kids have to get admitted to the hospital, half have some broken bone, and a quarter end up in the intensive care unit. Our general surgeon colleagues at Children’s Medical Center also recently showed that ATV injuries at our trauma center went up 77% during the COVID era, so we have unfortunately been seeing more of these injuries over the past few years.”

At any age, safety is key when using ATVs and lawn mowers. Please be careful as we head into warmer weather and outdoor activities.

Scoliosis Awareness Month: What is Scoliosis?

Scoliosis Awareness Month: What is Scoliosis?

What is it?
Scoliosis is not a disease. It is an abnormal curvature of the spine. In addition to the spine curving sideways, it also twists, making the ribs (which are attached to the spine) look uneven. This may cause a prominence or a “bump” on the back. Other signs include a shoulder or hip that looks higher than the other or the chest may appear uneven. Scoliosis is usually a painless condition. Children with scoliosis are no more likely than kids without scoliosis to have back pain.

The diagnosis of scoliosis is confirmed by taking an X‐ray of the spine. If a curve measures more than 10 degrees, it is called scoliosis.

Who has it?
Scoliosis usually occurs in early adolescence and becomes more noticeable during a growth spurt. Approximately 0.5 percent of young people develop scoliosis that requires treatment. Girls have scoliosis eight times more often than boys. Sometimes scoliosis can be found in several family members, for several generations.

Why does it happen?
There are several different types of scoliosis that affect children.

Idiopathic Scoliosis
The most common type of scoliosis is idiopathic, which means the exact cause is not known. Idiopathic scoliosis can occur in infants, toddlers and young children, but the majority of cases occur from age 10 to the time a child is fully grown. Scoliosis tends to run in families. It is not a disease that is caught from someone else like a cold. There is nothing you could have done to prevent it. It is not caused by carrying heavy books, backpacks or purses, slouching, sleeping wrong or from a lack of calcium.

Congenital scoliosis
Congenital means that you are born with the condition. Congenital scoliosis starts at the spine forms very early in pregnancy. Part of one or more of the vertebra does not form completely, or the vertebra does not separate properly. Other abnormalities may also be present such as ribs may be missing or there can be ribs that are fused together. This type of scoliosis can be associated with other health issues including heart and kidney problems.

Neuromuscular scoliosis
Any medical condition that affects the muscles and the nerves can lead to scoliosis and this is known as neuromuscular scoliosis. This is most commonly due to muscle imbalance and/or weakness. Examples of neuromuscular conditions that can lead to scoliosis include cerebral palsy, spina bifida and muscular dystrophy.

How is it found?
Finding scoliosis is easy when the back is examined closely but it can be missed if someone isn’t looking for it. Parents or friends might notice the curve, but most curves are found through a school screening program or by a pediatrician. A trained examiner can detect even a slight curve when a person bends over to touch her or his toes. If a curve is suspected, a referral is often made to an orthopedic doctor. Print this PDF.

What may be noticed on someone who has scoliosis:

  1. One shoulder may be higher than the other.
  2. One scapula (shoulder blade) may be higher or more prominent than the other.
  3. When the arms hang loosely at the side of the body, there may be more space between the arm and the body on one side.
  4. One hip may appear to be higher than the other.
  5. The head may not be centered exactly over the pelvis.
  6. The waist may be flattened on one side; skin creases may be present on one side of the waist.

What are the types of curves?
Curves occur in the spine between the neck and the pelvis. They are named depending on their location. The most common type is in the upper back (thoracic) and tends to curve to the right. Other curves are in the lower (lumbar) spine. Many children have both types of curves.

How are curves treated?
Treatment depends on how big the curve is when it’s detected and how much growth is left. Curves can worsen during the major growth spurts. Curves less than 20 degrees may not need any treatment except to be checked by the doctor from time to time until the child has stopped growing.

If a child is still growing and the curve is greater than 20 degrees, the doctor might recommend wearing a brace. Bracing will not correct a curve. The goal of bracing is to help prevent the curve from getting worse during growth. Braces must be worn as prescribed by the doctor during the growing years in order to be effective. After growth is completed or if the curve does not respond to bracing, the brace is no longer worn.

If a curve is advanced, the doctor may suggest an operation to correct the scoliosis. Allowing a large curve to progress could interfere with heart and lung function in later years. The most common type of operation is called posterior spinal instrumentation and fusion. Instrumentation refers to metal rods and screws that are attached to the spine to hold it in the corrected position. Fusion refers to the bone graft that is placed along the spine making the vertebrae one solid piece.

Learn more about the importance of scoliosis screening.

Get to Know our Staff: Katie Sloma, Therapy Services

Get to Know our Staff: Katie Sloma, Therapy Services

What is your job title/your role at Scottish Rite for Children?
I am a sports physical therapist helping athletes return to sports and performance.

What do you do on a daily basis or what sort of duties do you have at work?
I provide patient care, stay up to date in research and current evidence-based practices and offer patient and parent education.

What was your first job? What path did you take to get here or what led you to Scottish Rite?
My job at Scottish Rite was my first job after graduating physical therapy school. As a former softball player, I participated in PT several times throughout my career and wanted to be a part of the process in returning athletes to the sports they love to play.

What do you enjoy most about Scottish Rite?
I love being able to work with such an amazing team every day that are all a crucial part of helping kids return to activities they love.

Tell us something about your job that others might not already know?
I get to catch and throw with our baseball and softball players as they are returning to activity and love that I can still get the chance to do this.

Where is the most interesting place you’ve been?
Scotland – I was able to go to St. Andrews golf course.

What is your favorite game or sport to watch and play?
Football is my favorite sport to watch, and softball is my favorite sport to play.

 If you could go back in time, what year would you travel to?
The 60s or 70s for their music!

What’s one fun fact about yourself?
I play in a sand volleyball league and a pickleball league.